Friday, August 31, 2012

On Writing 'The Secretary' (GC Ch. 4)

Chapter 4
Title: The Secretary
Words: 3,676
Quote: "You're Bruce Wayne's secretary? My, how the mighty have fallen!" — Selina Kyle to Valencia Carter
SongThis Boy by Franz Ferdinand on Grooveshark





The Title
I always wanted to have uniformity across chapter titles. Whenever you hit the chapter drop-down menu on FanFiction.Net, it looks very neat when there's some sort of theme or pattern with the chapter titles. When I realized how well it would work out with the last chapter titled "The End," I knew I had to go with the "The [Something]" trend.

But Chapter 4 was the first time I faced a dilemma about the chapter title. Throughout planning and writing the chapter, it was called "The Billionaire" in my head, and the tagline would have been "Such is the life of your typical, bored, billionaire bachelor," an Alfred quote. But somewhere along the line, probably 3,000+ words in, I realized this chapter is so much more about Valencia than it is about Bruce.

Perhaps my choice of song, "This Boy" by Franz Ferdinand, should have been changed too, but it simply fit in so well with the playboy image that Bruce portrays to the public, and that is truly the cause of all the drama that unfolds in the office that day. My second choice would have been "Jacqueline," also by Franz: "It's always better on holiday / So much better on holiday / That's why we only work when we need the money."

The 40th Floor of Wayne Tower
There's a lot of description about the office atmosphere at Wayne Enterprises. When it became clear that most of the chapter would be from Valencia's POV, I knew I needed to include her perspective (and derision) about her fellow workmates, so I elaborated on the description of her fellow applicants from Chapter 2 and applied it to the whole office culture. The end result was something straight out of "Mad Men." Basically, think of the 40th floor of Wayne Tower as the offices of Sterling Cooper from the first two seasons: very 50s, well-dressed secretaries catering to executives' every whim, etc.

Also, side note, but the Wayne Tower I imagine is the one from "The Dark Knight" and "TDK Rises." (It's the moderately tall, black, rectangular structure, as opposed to the very CGI-looking one in "Batman Begins.") While the center-of-the-city, tallest-building theme certainly would have worked too, there's just something very real about the later alternative.

New Characters Abound
Chapter 4 saw the introduction of four new, albeit relatively minor characters. Let's start with the pair of security guards, Crispus Allen and Clancy O'Hara. I kept picturing the lobby of Wayne Tower as this glass and steel Mecca for the Gotham business district, as busy as a train station all day long. Of course it needed to have security guards, so, like I had in previous chapters, I turned to Batman wikia for name inspiration.

In the comics/original TV series, Clancy O'Hara was one of the "incorruptible" and had worked himself up the ranks to become the chief of the Gotham City Police Department. Crispus Allen was just a regular but dedicated cop who worked under Commissioner Gordon, though he had misgivings about working with the vigilante Batman. Cris and Clance are decidedly demoted in my fic to newbie security guards at Wayne Tower. My tentative future plans for them was to be side of comic relief for Valencia when she's on the job.

There's not much to distinguish between Allen and O'Hara, and they could easily have been compressed into one character, but  I needed two security guards if Bruce had two ex-girlfriends. He was originally going to have only one, Selina Kyle, but I couldn't shake that image of him in "Batman Begins," walking in with a European model on each arm. After all, Bruce Wayne does what every billionaire playboy would do, only he does it bigger and better.

As almost everyone knows, Selina Kyle is Catwoman in the comics and movies. I gave her a very different background in this story, transforming her into a socialite from one of Gotham's first families. In the comics and now "The Dark Knight Rises," Selina has a much tougher, from the Narrows sort of childhood. Natalia Knight, also known as Nocturna, had a similar storyline as Catwoman in the comics and got a similar treatment in my fic.

Nicknames
I gave Selina and Natalia nicknames simply because I didn't want to say outright that Bruce's clingy exes were Catwoman and Nocturna. Throughout the chapter, Bruce refers to them solely as 'Lina' and 'Tali.' In fact, I was hoping someone might jump the gun and mistake Tali as short for Talia al Ghul. And such was my cheap imitation of the good Christopher Nolan run-around.

As much as I absolutely adore Valencia's name, I knew nicknames were going to be in order for her. We already have seen Alfred call her 'Miss Lenci,' and this chapter reveals her high school nickname was 'Valley.' At first it does look rather odd — I played around with spellings, and Vallie does NOT work — but 'Valencia' is just not for everyday use. Even 'Miss Carter' is shorter to say than that. In the future, Bruce will be shortening Valencia's name too.

Flamboyant Bruce
Okay, so Bruce Wayne admittedly dresses a bit more flamboyantly in Gotham's Cinderella than he does in the movies. As much as I appreciate Christian Bale in his staid Armani suits, I think he could afford to indulge in a little more flair. His flashier attire is in line with the philosophy that real men wear pink, which I subscribe to wholeheartedly. The dark grey and lilac combination that is described in this chapter was originally supposed to be his attire for Chapter 2: The Interview, but he went for something a little more showy (light gray and sunflower yellow) for his first meeting with Valencia.

The Pen Tuck Scene
For some reason, I sat on this chapter for a very long time. It's not that I really got stuck anywhere, but I did tweak it again and again. Originally, it was longer, pushing about 3,700 words (which is short compared to later chapters), but it was pared down to about 3,300.

It's hard to remember now, but I think the issue was that I wanted more Bruce/Valencia interaction in the chapter. There was this smoking lounge scene that was supposed to show a bit of their dynamic, a scene that was one of the first I ever wrote for GC, but I ended up cutting it pretty early into writing Chapter 3. (I will post a draft of it soon.)

The ear/pen tuck thing just came to me when I was trying to end the chapter after Selina and Valencia's showdown. Up to this day, it is one my favorite scenes because I think it conveys perfectly just who Bruce and Valencia really are. Valencia is trying very hard to be strictly professional, and I think that betrays how young she is and how desperate she is to be taken seriously. But there's an underlying passion in her that pops out, especially in the face of adversity, and that recurs again and again in future chapters. She is spurred into action when there's something to be worked against.

Perhaps this doesn't come across in the movies as much as I like, but Bruce flirts really well. It's like second nature to him, but he has to put in the extra effort with Valencia because she's holding him at arm's length, which no one else does. He likes the challenge; it puts a bit of the fun back into the charade he keeps up, an act that has become tired and jaded for him, as evident from his conversation with Alfred in the beginning of the chapter.

The seductiveness of Bruce first taking and then returning the pen she has tucked behind her ear also set the tone for future chapters. There's this ambiguity about whether they're doing or saying certain things. Is it a challenge to see how the other will react? A bit of a joke/for the sake of irony? Because they truly are attracted to one another? Frankly, it's a combination of all three, and that is the sum of Bruce and Valencia's complicated relationship.

So What Did Valencia Say?
To be honest, I had no clue what Valencia whispered to Selina when I published the chapter, and I didn't know for a long while afterward. (Yes, it's rather convenient Bruce didn't overheard what she said.) But that mystery has since been solved, and you will be let in on the secret in the very last chapter of "Gotham's Cinderella." How's that for a teaser!

Thursday, August 23, 2012

Valencia Carter, Chapter 1

Valencia Carter, Chapter 1


Green dress
$24 - fashionunion.com


H M trench coat
$47 - hm.com


H M ballet flat
$24 - hm.com


Antler mesh bag
lordandtaylor.com



Bruce Wayne, Chapter 1

Social Media Launch

Hello, everyone!

This week marks the official social media launch of InkFairy Fiction. If you've gone on the blog or my FanFiction.Net profile during the last few days, you might have noticed that InkFairy has ventured a few steps further into the social media world.

Almost nine years ago exactly (August 19, 2003), I signed up for an account on FanFiction.Net. For more than eight years afterward, InkFairy was just that: an author page on FanFiction.Net with dubious updating. Then, last winter I decided to start a blog where I could post extra material, like deleted scenes and chapter commentaries, and so InkFairyFiction.blogspot.com was born.

A couple weeks ago, I started using Polyvore to put together the actual outfits I visualized Bruce and Valencia wearing in Gotham's Cinderella, and everything just spiralied from there. In the space of one all-nighter, I had started a Facebook page, YouTube channel, Twitter handle, and Pinterest board for InkFairy Fiction.

It is my intention that I will strive for uniformity across all accounts - in other words, there will be no Twitter-specific or Facebook-specific, etc. material. Most of the content will come straight from this blog, and I will then just post links onto Facebook and Twitter.

So without further ado, here is the complete InkFairy Fiction Social Network. Of course, if some new thing comes along and I can find some way to utilize it, it will be added to this list. (Tumblr, alas, I have yet to figure out a place for.)

 twitter.com/InkFairyFiction (@InkFairyFiction)

Please like/follow/subscribe to any or all of these accounts. My intent is to make the fanfiction reading experience as informative and interactive as possible, to share ideas and inspirations in different and dynamic ways, and to open and improve new channels of communication between authors and readers.

Thanks!
InkFairy

Thursday, August 16, 2012

A Detailed Timeline of Events


February 19, 1975: Bruce Wayne born
- He turns 30 in Batman Begins, which came out in 2005 and takes place in a presumably contemporary setting.
- There are conflicting reports about the exact date of his birthday, but February 19 came up more than once, and it happens to be my mom's birthday, so obviously we have a winner.

December 1983: Thomas and Martha Wayne murdered
- Though his age is never said in the beginning of Batman Begins, according to the comics/just about anything else you can find about Bruce Wayne's childhood, he was eight years old when his parents were killed.
- In the movie, it's clearly winter when the murder takes place. Bruce and his family are wearing coats, and I believe there's even a little swirl of snow in the alley when they leave the theater.
- I would bet that it was around holiday time when Bruce and his family decided to take their ill-fated trip into Gotham City. Bruce's father shows him the pearls he's going to give Mrs. Wayne as a present, probably for Christmas. Though a night at the opera might be a normal outing if you're a Wayne, they decide to take the train, which Bruce is obviously unfamiliar with, so maybe this is another holiday perk. Alfred doesn't drive them and he doesn't show up at the police station afterward, so maybe he was away visiting family for the holidays.

January 30, 1984: Valencia Carter born
- She had to be born after Bruce's parents were killed so that he would have no memory of her living in Wayne Manor. The precocious Bruce we see playing with Rachel around the grounds would surely have noticed and taken interest in a new baby in the house.

1984-1994: Bruce attends boarding school
- I went out on a bit of a limb and guessed that Bruce had a boarding school education. In the U.S., boarding schools are largely concentrated in the East Coast region. As Gotham City is traditionally located somewhere between New York City and Atlantic City, I don't think it would be too much of a stretch that he would be sent away at a relatively young age for schooling. The majority of boarding schools are for grades 9-12 or high school age, but there are a good number that take children as young as kindergarten age. Bruce would have been around grade 3 or 4.
- Of course there's Alfred to consider, and though I don't think Alfred would have wanted to send a young Bruce away, he might have made the decision to do so based on how difficult Bruce was finding it to move on, especially while living in Wayne Manor. As we see in Batman Begins, this still troubles Bruce well into young adulthood.
- Lastly and most importantly, it served the purpose of my story to have Bruce pretty much absent from Wayne Manor as Valencia was growing up, since they had never met before.

1994-1997: Bruce attends college
- This is purely guesswork, but I figured Bruce was probably a junior (third year) in college when he was expelled from Princeton. If he had been on track, he should have been graduating college by 1997. I'm going with the theory that Princeton was not the first Ivy League school he was kicked out of, and expulsion does tend to mess up one's credits, so he was probably a year or at least a semester behind.
- This also would explain why Rachel is presumably out of college and already working at a law firm when he returns, assuming they are the same age.

1994-1997: Valencia attends Brentwood Academy
- This is the elite private school Valencia's mother gets her into when she's 10 years old. In the comics, it's a high school, but I turned it into a junior high.

1997: Joe Chill's trial, Bruce disappears
- This year I figured out retroactively. The end of Batman Begins is 2005, the year of Bruce's 30th birthday. That takes place a few months after his return to Gotham, meaning he came back from the dead in 2004. He was missing for seven years, which means he ran away from Gotham in 1997.

1997-2004: Bruce roams the world
- Basically seven years of what Bruce tells Ra's Al Ghul: he was pretty much a vagabond, stole for food, got involved in international smuggling, and ended up in a Chinese prison. Somehow, somewhere he learned how to fight seven men at once.

1997-2000: Valencia attends Gotham Prep
-Gotham Prep, my creation entirely, is an elite, private, college preparatory school located in the Palisades. Though Bruce did not go here, it is where most of Gotham's wealthy send their kids to be educated. I guess it could be a boarding school that accepts day students as well.

Fall 2004: Bruce trains with the League of Shadows, returns to Gotham
- This comprises a relatively short part of Batman Begins, but I imagine that Bruce was there for several weeks, if not months, mastering their techniques and earning the trust of Ra's Al Ghul.
- When he returns, Bruce lays low for a couple weeks, then shows up at the Wayne Enterprises board meeting as Bruce Wayne, the billionaire playboy.
- Again, this is very fast in the movie, but it probably took a few months for him to set up his operation as Batman, so that would take care of the rest of fall 2004 and bring him to his birthday in February 2005.

February 19, 2005: Bruce defeats the League of Shadows (end of Batman Begins), Wayne Manor burns down
- Bruce's 30th birthday. He saves Rachel from Scarecrow, insults everyone at his birthday party, burns the Manor down, and keeps the League of Shadows from destroying Gotham via a very fancy form of biological warfare.

August 2005: The Dark Knight, Rachel Dawes dies
- The Dark Knight is set six months after Batman Begins. Though so much happens in that film, all the events happen right after one another. Not a lot of time passes, and my guess puts it at a month at most.

January 30, 2006: Valencia turns 22

February 19, 2006: Bruce turns 31

April 2006: Valencia returns to Gotham (GC Ch. 1-3)
- The Return: Bruce comes back from a business trip to London and fires his secretary, Wayne Manor is finished
- The Interview: Interviews are held for the position of Bruce's secretary, Bruce interviews Valencia
- The Disappointment: That night, Alfred tells Bruce all about Valencia

Valencia's Original History


This is what Alfred's monologue about Valencia's past looked like before I decided to add in Bruce. Aside from the little tweaks to transform this into a dialogue, there are a couple other things I would change: Talia Carter was 19 when she had Valencia, her name probably isn't Talia because of the similarity with an upcoming character's name, and I wouldn't have kept that part about Valencia's becoming depressed whenever they were apart. That's just not Valencia, though I think my point was to show the extent of her feelings for her boyfriend.




“Miss Valencia’s mother was sixteen years old when she arrived in Gotham. Her parents were upstanding, British citizens who kicked their daughter out of the house when they found out she was pregnant. Their housekeeper, a cousin of mine, sent Talia Carter to stay here at Wayne Manor until her parents relented. They never did.

“It was about a year after your parents’ death. Miss Talia knew nothing about housekeeping, but the staff soon fell in love with her. She was such a young, thoughtless yet kind-hearted thing, and we all thought Miss Valencia was the most beautiful baby ever born… saving yourself, of course.

“It was obvious from a very young age that Miss Valencia was quite intelligent. They tested her repeatedly in the schools, called her a genius and allowed her to skip a couple years. By the time she was ten, she was at Brentwood Academy.”

“The elite school here in the Palisades? Only the richest in Gotham can get their kids in, which is why my father didn’t want me to go there.”

“You never met Talia Carter. She got her daughter everything she possibly could, and then some. But as much as she loved her daughter and wanted the absolute best for her for her own sake, I believe part of it was fueled by revenge. She wanted to turn Miss Valencia into a wonder, a prodigy, and make her own parents sorry for abandoning her and missing out on helping raise their grandchild. So Miss Valencia had all the lessons, played all the sports, attended all the parties her mother thought necessary for her upbringing.

“Yet in many ways, Miss Valencia was the more adult of the pair of them, the more responsible one who got their bills paid on time and made sure the necessities came before everything else. I don’t think she ever cared much for playing the piano, swimming competitively or riding horses, but she seemed to bear her mother’s enthusiasm for all those things with a sort of…”

“Condescension?” The memory of his brief meeting with her surfaces in Bruce’s mind, the politely tolerant but loftily self-assured way she had addressed him.

The older man looks at him sharply. “I suppose you could call it that,” he says slowly, “an affectionately tempered sort of condescension. Her mother wanted her to be a prodigy, so she played the part as she did everything else—wonderfully. And it worked… for a while.

“Miss Valencia was able to get into Gotham Preparatory Academy on the Wayne Scholarship, which was started by your parents and funds the education of one outstanding student at Gotham Prep for four years,” he elaborates, seeing the blank look on Bruce’s face. “I tried to talk Miss Talia out of it. She was much too young, only 13, and she didn’t have the advantages of her classmates, but it was too good a chance to pass up, so she went, and that’s where it all started.

“He was a Wayne Scholar as well, but a couple of years ahead of her. The more she saw of him, the less we saw of her, and it frightened her mother. Miss Talia even began to talk of withdrawing her from the school if she persisted in seeing him, but for the first time in her life Miss Valencia absolutely refused to do as her mother wished. So Miss Valencia stayed at Gotham Prep, and they became inseparable.

“They thought the world of each other, and everyone could see it wouldn’t—couldn’t—end well. They were too young, too... in love, if that’s possible. When they were together, everyone else didn’t matter anymore, and the bouts of depression and despair that Miss Valencia suffered when they were apart for any amount of time or during one of their few fights was almost painful to witness.

“When he graduated, Miss Talia thought that would be the end of it, but he gave up a scholarship to MIT, opting instead to study at Gotham University in order to stay close to her. Miss Valencia began to talk about going to Gotham University once she graduated, and this was the final straw for her mother. Miss Talia began to make plans to move back to London upon Miss Valencia’s graduation, but then something happened that changed everything.

“You see, he wasn’t bad person—he seemed to care a great deal for Miss Valencia—but he’d grown up with the wrong sort of people, starting with his father. They lived in the Narrows and one day, when Miss Valencia was visiting him, she walked in on a fight between father and son. He ended up pulling a knife on his father and wounding him severely.

“There was a trial, and it caught the entire city’s attention. With the suspect and the main witness both Wayne Scholars, the company’s lawyers got involved, since it would be bad for business if he were convicted. Needless to say, he was cleared of all charges on the basis of self-defense, but they didn’t stop there. They unearthed evidence against his father, his ties to drug rings and the black market, thousands of dollars of gambling debts. They were even able to implicate some of the other criminals and locked them all up. They fed the media a trumped up version of his life as a disadvantaged youth struggling to break free of the world of crime he had grown up in, and they absolutely loved it.

“Miss Valencia got her share of the media attention as well. She was the faithful girlfriend who never left his side during the entire trial, a maid’s daughter who was on the verge of becoming the youngest graduate at Gotham Prep and valedictorian too. The company was determined that they would live out a fairytale. Their happiness would show that Wayne Enterprises’ philanthropic spirit hadn’t died with Thomas Wayne.

“They talked about running away from it all, the pressure and scrutiny, the high expectations placed on them. Sometimes I wonder if things would have ended better if I hadn’t interfered, but I did. Her mother locked her in a room the night they planned to leave. Miss Valencia made herself sick crying and yelling, and we were forced to sedate her. He didn’t show up the next day, or the next. Her mother was convinced he had run away without her, and as the days passed, Miss Valencia seemed to start thinking the same thing… until his body washed up on the riverbank.

“Miss Valencia was supposed to have met him on a bridge that night, and while he waited for her, his father’s associates, the ones that had been scapegoated by the lawyers, attacked him. To distance themselves and the company, the lawyers let leak a story that he had been addicted to drugs, that the attack was a result of a drug deal gone wrong. They were poised to continue exploiting Valencia, setting her up as the innocent victim in all of this, but they never had the chance.

“She’d somehow gotten her hands on the sleeping pills we’d given her, and she took the whole bottle. We barely got her to the hospital in time. She very nearly died. Her heart stopped for a few minutes. But by some miracle, she survived, and before she was up and about, her mother had her on a plane to London. I later heard from my cousin that Miss Talia made amends with her parents, who helped take care of Miss Valencia.

On Writing The Disappointment (GC Ch. 3)

Chapter 3
Title: The Disappointment
Words: 3,301
Quote: "So she wasn't a Gotham Prep prodigy who got caught up in the city's underworld of crime, drugs and murder?" — Bruce Wayne to Alfred Pennyworth about Valencia Carter
Song:Only The Young by Brandon Flowers on Grooveshark




The Birth of a Chapter
Sometimes chapters are too short, and sometimes chapters are too long. Mine tend toward the latter.

I mentioned in the previous commentary that Linda Page was added as filler, but the reason why Chapter 2 was coming up short in the first place was that I decided to turn the explanation of Valencia's past into a chapter by itself. The earliest draft had the telling of her story as a joint venture between Alfred and Lucius Fox, after hours in Wayne Tower. (Alfred conveniently decided to make the trip up to the 40th floor after waiting to drive Bruce home.) I much prefer what I decided to go with in the end, with Fox ceding the responsibility over to Alfred. Plot cliffhanger endings — as opposed to the dramatic action variety — are always quite fun.

The Timeline
The bright side of chapter splitting is that the second chapter gets written a lot more easily and quickly, and it helped that I knew exactly what needed to be said. Before I even started writing out Chapter 1, I had mapped out all of Valencia's history so that it would work with the timeline of Bruce's life, based on the events of Batman Begins and The Dark Knight. A little Googling research on my part revealed to me that The Dark Knight takes place only about six months after the events of Batman Begins. In retrospect, that makes a lot of sense because of the lead-in to the Joker at the of Batman Begins — obviously, Batman wouldn't have put off looking into the Joker issue for two to three years — but I had been under the impression that TDK took place some time after BB. Fortunately, my misunderstanding ended up helping my story, as it shorted by two to three years the sizable age difference between Bruce and Valencia.

Here's a simple timeline of events leading up to the start of Gotham's Cinerella. I'll be posting a more detailed version right after this, complete with detailed explanations of my reasoning/guesswork, and I will try to update it as the chapters progress.

  • February 19, 1975: Bruce Wayne born
  • December 1983: Thomas and Martha Wayne murdered
  • January 30, 1984: Valencia Carter born
  • 1984-1994: Bruce attends boarding school
  • 1994-1997: Bruce attends college
  • 1997: Joe Chill's trial, Bruce disappears
  • 1997-2004: Bruce roams the world
  • 1997-2000: Valencia attends Gotham Prep
  • 2000: Valencia leaves Gotham
  • fall 2004: Bruce trains with the League of Shadows
  • February 19, 2005: Bruce defeats the League of Shadows (end of Batman Begins), Wayne Manor burns down
  • August-September 2005: The Dark Knight, Rachel Dawes dies
  • January 30, 2006: Valencia turns 22
  • February 19, 2006: Bruce turns 31
  • April 2006: The Return, The Interview, The Disappointment (Ch. 1-3 of GC)

So, long story short, that puts us about seven months after the end of The Dark Knight and about 14 months after Wayne Manor burns down at the end of Batman Begins. (That's probably not enough time to rebuild an entire mansion, but hey, what else is fanfiction for?)

Storytime with Alfred
In the original version of the chapter, Alfred pretty much spoke uninterrupted, but it didn't sound at all natural and even I couldn't get through it without getting bored. To try to fix this, I broke up the narrative by adding in Bruce's asking questions, making it play out as more of a dialogue between the two of them. Only once in the final version do two paragraphs of Alfred talking appear without some sort of a break. Though at first I wasn't in love with it, I think it helps show that Bruce is truly curious about Valencia, not just because she intrigued him during their interview, but also (perhaps more?) because of her relationship with Alfred. I will be posting the original monologue version shortly.

A Debutante Comes Out
My original plan for Valencia was that she went to school with the rich kids but remained pretty much an outsider. That would have been what brought her and her boyfriend together, both of their being scholarship kids and from less affluent backgrounds, working hard while their classmates were attending debutante balls and such. As I continued planning out her story, however, it soon became apparent that she would require more experience in the upper-class world for everything to work out and not be too far-fetched.

So the Wayne Scholarship evolved into something equally social and scholarly. As Alfred explains, it became a way for Wayne Enterprises and the Wayne Foundation to improve its image, especially right after Bruce disappeared from Gotham. The Wayne Scholars became mini Gotham celebrities, something that grew exponentially and was exploited in Valencia's case because of the scandal of what happened with her boyfriend's father. Though Valencia was never completely accepted by all of the elite, as will become apparent in later chapters, the divide between her and her classmates was much smaller than I had anticipated.

Only the Young
I am a huge fan of The Killers, and their music will certainly be showing up in future chapters. Lead singer Brandon Flowers' "Only the Young" felt like a perfect fit for this unexpected chapter. There's a kind of moonlight quality to it that is in accord with the late-night setting, the early morning hours during which Alfred and Bruce are talking, before the sun has risen. It's not a happy song, but there's a wistful hopefulness to it that I think reflects how Alfred views Valencia's story. He wants to hope everything will work out well for her, but so much tragedy has happened in her life that even wishing that is hard to do.